Sunday, August 7, 2011

Reading: Jung in Context (P. Homans) Ch 4

p 84. Homans makes some fascinating comments on Narcissism and Otherness, that essentially the obsession with self is a relational one: without the other there is no question of self. Narcissism takes place and Self-esteem and Identity comes into creation through the differentiation between other and self. This evokes the process of the I-Thou, God-Man,Father/Mother(Parent)-Child: sacred and profane relations intermingle and manifest themselves as a process of individuation or narcissism. That said, the contents of one's life would inform this overall process: religious,intellectual, cultural, social environment and an individual's personal relationship with them as well as with parents and significant other persons. What then is the collective versus the personal elements of unconsciousness? The collective portion would be all the external, environments (religious, cultural, ethnic, intellectual factors) while the personal would be one's relationships to significant other persons (most often parents) and self. In a sense this is the story of the self and extra-self in the creation of a stable personality. However, the personality is always vulnerable to disruption from within; that mind has a self-disruptive function that is not strictly rational (Read Lear to clarify thoughts). To what extent is the above description culturally bounded to the judeo-christian West? In what ways is the notion of individuation or autonomy as the goal of the above intra-psychic process?

No comments:

Post a Comment